Doctor Who: The Angels Take Manhattan review

And a lovely tie up it was. The bringing back of the young Amelia Pond as a closing shot was a welcome touch, and it feels like it topped and tailed the story of Rory and Amy extremely well. Karen Gillan in particular has been strong in her assertion that she won’t be back in the show, even for guest appearances, and in the nicest sense, we hope she won’t be. It feels like the natural end of their journey, and if the temptation to bring her back can be resisted, then that’d be all the better in this case. Rory’s dad is welcome back anytime, of course.

Not that Amy Pond won’t be missed. Amy and Rory had one final adventure here, and Steven Moffat’s script gave both Gillan and Arthur Darvill an awful lot of work to do. Confronted with their potential separation, there was humour, action and emotion, and the performances from Gillan and Darvill were both up to the job. We’ve said before that we’re particularly going to miss Arthur Darvill. His performance as Rory has evolved and impressed more and more as the episodes have rolled on.

Matt Smith, though, was also in tip top form, and the foreboding warning that his Doctor should never travel alone came through loud and clear here. It felt like quite a few things were being established for him to consider in the next run of episodes (River, after all, implies that he’s gone too far erasing himself from history, basically the reversal of the problem he was up against before), and it’ll be interesting to see how those threads develop. For now, not for the first time nor the last, The Doctor was faced with losing dear friends and companions (and just how special Amy was to him was explored in The Power Of Three), and Smith sold the heartbreak and loneliness of this tremendously well.

We also got the return of River Song here. It’s always good to see Alex Kingston in Doctor Who, and given that it was her parents who were going away, it was pretty much inevitable she’d be around for their farewell. We don’t get vintage River, but her purpose here seems more to be to keep the Doctor, Amy and Rory in some kind of check. That, and she’s also the author of the book that provides the spoiler-filled guide to the episode. She had her moments too, especially where she disguised breaking her wrist. And, of course, when she affirmed to her mother the way to get back to Rory at the end. The Doctor may have forgotten that it was her saying goodbye to her parents, but Kingston’s performance certainly didn’t.

Then there were the Angels. Along with the likes of The Silence, the Weeping Angels are one of the superb new monsters that Steven Moffat has introduced into the world of Doctor Who, but here, they felt a little diluted. The big Statue Of Liberty Angel, for instance, appeared not a million miles removed from the daft massive Cyberman in The Next Doctor, and there was very much a sense that the Angels were out of the shadows, and a little less effective as a result. In The Time Of Angels, for instance, Moffat managed to up the creep factor of them with a dose of Japanese horror. The closest he got here? The baby Angels were good, and opened up a way for them to go in the future. And the smiling Angel proved quite unsettling, too. Yet they didn’t feel anywhere near as scary this time around. In fact at one stage, when one Angel is said by River to be screaming, we’re almost left feeling sorry for them. That’s something of a change in the audience’s relationship with them.

Just to temper all of that: while it does seem odd that the weakest part of The Angels Take Manhattan were the Angels themselves, they’re still welcome and impressive foes. To keep their level of impact, though, it might work best if they were kept off the regular monsters rota.

You May Like Also

  • Share on Facebook (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Twitter (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Linkedin (opens in a new tab)
  • where now for Doctor Who series 7?
  • Twitter feed for faster news and bad jokes right here
  • Share on Facebook (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Twitter (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Linkedin (opens in a new tab)
  • The Angels Take Manhattan
  • Doctor Who: The Angels Take Manhattan spoiler-free review
  • Doctor Who: Top 10 Best Pond Moments
  • "Doctor Who: Asylum Of The Daleks Review"
  • Doctor Who: Flux Episode 4 Review - Village of the Angels
  • Black Friday 2021’s Best Video Game Deals: PS5, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, and More
  • Best Tech Deals for Black Friday 2021: PC Gaming, VR, Mobile Devices, and More
  • The Best Geeky Holiday Gifts on eBay For Everyone On Your List